Post by Janice Dickinson on Nov 12, 2016 23:21:17 GMT -5
Frostbite
Aline:
Cate:
Elsa (Expressive eyes):
Emma: Aline...well done. I love your strength
Cate....beautiful bit could be better
Elsa....I like this a lot. The Modelling is very strong
Utada: Aline, I like the outfit because it's different and daring. Your body language is great, but like the other judges, your face throws me off a bit. It's the one weak point of the shot for me.
Cate, your head really does kinda ruin this shot for me. It's like you were playing a video game and entered Big Head mode. I do like the dress and how you accessorized, though.
Elsa, you cosplay is fantastic. Great energy and movement from the outfit and posing and it looks very accurate to me.
Team Hara-Kiri
Xiao Wen:
Victoria:
Poison Ivy:
Emma: Xiao.......catwalks are hard to give good fac . So I don't hate it purely on the face. The knees.....I'm just not a fan sorry
Victoria......beautiful
Ivy.....also beautiful but I think we needed more energy for this
Utada: Xiao, you look so completely bored. I do like the dress and you have good body language, though. The quality is a bit off, though. However, since this is a candid shot of a runway instead of a modeling shoot, it definitely calls for leniency there.
Victoria, I love this shot. The dress is wonderful, the posing's spot on, and I just can't find fault with it.
Ivy, I thought Victoria was going to have the strongest shot after seeing hers, but then I scroll a couple inches down a see this. Fantastic representation that hits all points of Poison Ivy's character, for me.
Ivy League
Fei Fei:
Penelope:
Quiet:
Emma: Fei Fei.....owning this shit. Great face great walk
Penelope.....slight slouch looks bored
Quiet.....is pretty damn amazing
Utada: Fei Fei, I love the outfit. I love the attitude. I just love everything about this shot. One of my favorite runway shots in a long time.
Penelope, I love the dress and I think the posing could've worked without that face. With the face, you look absolutely miserable there. That's he only thing that really detracts from the shot for me.
Quiet, I love the attention to detail paid to this shot. You also give us great posing and great energy. Your cosplay shots are really turning out to be the strongest shots this round.
Neon Demons
Abbey Lee:
Elle:
Marceline:
Emma: Abbey.....fierce....but small
Elle.....cutest photo in so long. Stunning
Marceline.....what on Earth is Going on here lol. Nice pic tho
Utada: Abbey, I'm just going t have to echo the other judges: cropping wold've helped this shot so much. You looked dwarfed in it, as it is. However, I do love everything else about it, though. The fashion's great, the walk is fierce, and we get good energy.
Elle, it looks like someone ripped off your left arm. However, I do like that we're getting a different look from you here (compared to the other celebrities). The dress is interesting and you have great energy (something I feel is very important for candid shots like Runway and Red Carpet).
Marceline, your fashion is a bit basic when compared to other cosplayers this round, but I think the added levitation helps make up for that. It gives us something interesting about the shot since it would've been a bit boring, otherwise. Still, it looks true to character to me, so an overall good shot.
Aline:
Cate:
Elsa (Expressive eyes):
Rarity: As this is the final round, my critiques will be short.
Aline's walk is fierce up until her face, in particular, her eyes, where I feel there is a blankness. I hate that outfit.
Cate is everything. No, really, such a great red carpet.
Elsa, YAAAAAS! It's phenom. I would change nothing.
Aline's walk is fierce up until her face, in particular, her eyes, where I feel there is a blankness. I hate that outfit.
Cate is everything. No, really, such a great red carpet.
Elsa, YAAAAAS! It's phenom. I would change nothing.
Morgan: I, Morgan Freeman, appreciate that outfit more than you can imagine, please dont bunch up the fabric in what I find to be very interesting aspects of a females body, its just a tease. You are owning this runway!
Cate I love your fashion and your presence but when it comes to your face I'm seeing aged once again and a sense of tension and stress. I can help to allievate those feelings you have if you let me.
Elsa this is a wonderfully accurate character role play, just watch for those awkward fingers they look very Edward Scissorhand-ish
Cate I love your fashion and your presence but when it comes to your face I'm seeing aged once again and a sense of tension and stress. I can help to allievate those feelings you have if you let me.
Elsa this is a wonderfully accurate character role play, just watch for those awkward fingers they look very Edward Scissorhand-ish
Janice: This is a high fashion and unusual outfit, the walk is extremely strong, but I do agree with Rarity, in that it's fierce all the way up to the face. I don't agree that there's not intensity in the eyes, but I do think the make up makes Aline quiet aged.
Cate's red carpet is amazing. It's near perfect, the only issue I have is the head looks hunched, and in turn, makes it look photoshopped onto the body.
Elsa's cosplay. Those legs are everything. The execution is perfect in the action, however, I think the make up and hair is the part where it could be improved. Elsa's make up and hair are a bit more dramatic. This is a bit more subdued.
Emma: Aline...well done. I love your strength
Cate....beautiful bit could be better
Elsa....I like this a lot. The Modelling is very strong
Utada: Aline, I like the outfit because it's different and daring. Your body language is great, but like the other judges, your face throws me off a bit. It's the one weak point of the shot for me.
Cate, your head really does kinda ruin this shot for me. It's like you were playing a video game and entered Big Head mode. I do like the dress and how you accessorized, though.
Elsa, you cosplay is fantastic. Great energy and movement from the outfit and posing and it looks very accurate to me.
Team Hara-Kiri
Xiao Wen:
Victoria:
Poison Ivy:
Rarity: My only complaint with Xiao Wen is her lack of eye-contact. It's detracting from ultimate fierceness.
I'm living for Victoria's pose, but that dress has got to go.
I would have preferred a full bodied cosplay, but Ivy is the standout in this crowd. Such a star.
Morgan: Xiao Wen, this isn't working for me you look disinterested and bored in this photo and not in a modelesque way either it literally looks like you've just woken up and got on stage. Those hunched shoulders along with your fashion piece is making your head look too close to your shoulders/
Victoria its a bit too simple for me, and I'm feeling like you've had a mishap with some fake tan - your body color looks so different to your face color that it looks like your face has been photoshopped on. It's a bit too confusing for my liking.
Ivy now this is what I'm talking about, even without being a full body shot I look at this and see Ivy 100% with a confident and beautful model who knows her angles. Well done!
Janice: Xiao Wen looks magical, I think. The outfit is everything. The walk is strong. However, I do agree with Morgan and Rarity in that eye contact would've made this appear more fierce and less disinterested.
I love the way the dress fits Victoria, though it's not a very appealing colour, it does strangely look good on her. I think the problem here is the lighting, making this silver dress look the putrid olive colour.
A full body cosplay would have been wonderful from Ivy, but the angles and modelling of the model look flawless. It exudes the sex appeal of Ivy without being so hoochie.
Emma: Xiao.......catwalks are hard to give good fac . So I don't hate it purely on the face. The knees.....I'm just not a fan sorry
Victoria......beautiful
Ivy.....also beautiful but I think we needed more energy for this
Utada: Xiao, you look so completely bored. I do like the dress and you have good body language, though. The quality is a bit off, though. However, since this is a candid shot of a runway instead of a modeling shoot, it definitely calls for leniency there.
Victoria, I love this shot. The dress is wonderful, the posing's spot on, and I just can't find fault with it.
Ivy, I thought Victoria was going to have the strongest shot after seeing hers, but then I scroll a couple inches down a see this. Fantastic representation that hits all points of Poison Ivy's character, for me.
Ivy League
Fei Fei:
Penelope:
Quiet:
Rarity: Fei Fei is absolutely rocking the runway. She is the strongest in this team for the round.
Penelope, I've always disliked that shoulder hunched forward pose, it just looks like bad posture. Still very strong as that is my only complaint.
I'm living for Quiet. Literally one of the best cosplays I've ever seen. Great work.
Morgan: Fei Fei I like the confidence and small smile playing in your face but I'm not a fan of the shadowing accross your face and the overload of accessories you've got on
Penelope this is a beautiful gown, I dont feel like you are appreciating the moment here with your bored facial expression I would have expected to see more of a humble light excitment from you
Quiet well don't you look like a strong dangerous and loaded lady just like I like them. Althoug too many abs tha look a bit zombie like can make Morgan Freeman Jr falter a little bit when it comes to action time, theres only so much muscle I can compete with.
Janice: Of the submissions for runway this round, Fei Fei is the strongest for me. She's got style, she's got flair, and she's there... That's how she became The Nanny? And channelling Fran Fine is never a bad thing.
Penelope's gown is beautiful and well fitting. I would have lost the trim of it though. I agree that the hunch gives it lose some energy, and a good posture could have elevated it.
Quiet's picture is fantastic. I love the added touch of her 'appearing' from her camouflaged state. It is also one of the best, and most detailed cosplays I've seen.
Emma: Fei Fei.....owning this shit. Great face great walk
Penelope.....slight slouch looks bored
Quiet.....is pretty damn amazing
Utada: Fei Fei, I love the outfit. I love the attitude. I just love everything about this shot. One of my favorite runway shots in a long time.
Penelope, I love the dress and I think the posing could've worked without that face. With the face, you look absolutely miserable there. That's he only thing that really detracts from the shot for me.
Quiet, I love the attention to detail paid to this shot. You also give us great posing and great energy. Your cosplay shots are really turning out to be the strongest shots this round.
Neon Demons
Abbey Lee:
Elle:
Marceline:
Rarity: Abbey Lee's is a little small, but it could just be the site shrinking it so I'm going to let it pass. Honestly, cropping it so there wasn't so much background would have helped. She's rocking the runway, though, so great work there!
I love Elle's, if only because she's so different from the other three celebrities this round. She is smiling like she really means it and not because she's on camera. It's infectious and I do love the dress.
Marceline, ABSOLUTELY! Going the extra mile to levitating gives this cosplay such a unique feel and I am so thrilled. Great work!
Morgan: I agree with Rarity that some cropping would have made you appear to be more center staged but even with a large background behind you my eyes go straight to you strutting yourself on the runway, you look great a real natural!
Elle you look real here, not posed or taking on a false persona which is good. Although even in our natural state we need to be mindful of our limb placement so not to make ourselves look amputated with a midget hand appearing at our hip.
This is a nice simple cosplay with the added touch of magic. I guess I was looking for something with more extreme color and boldness given Marceline's track record but different isn't always bad.
Janice: I am in unison with Rarity and Morgan. Cropping would have made this perfect. Otherwise, strong presence, strong face, strong walk. Amazing outfit.
Elle looks great. Probably the best red carpet overall, I'd say. The face is great, the dress is amazing, and I don't really mind so much about the amputeed look.
Marceline, as I said before: WTF HAX?! Great touch for that in this coplay. Great artistry on the photoshoppers part. I was also looking for something a bit more extreme here. With Quiet, Ivy and Elsa in the cosplay round looking amazing, it's hard to stand out between them.
Emma: Abbey.....fierce....but small
Elle.....cutest photo in so long. Stunning
Marceline.....what on Earth is Going on here lol. Nice pic tho
Utada: Abbey, I'm just going t have to echo the other judges: cropping wold've helped this shot so much. You looked dwarfed in it, as it is. However, I do love everything else about it, though. The fashion's great, the walk is fierce, and we get good energy.
Elle, it looks like someone ripped off your left arm. However, I do like that we're getting a different look from you here (compared to the other celebrities). The dress is interesting and you have great energy (something I feel is very important for candid shots like Runway and Red Carpet).
Marceline, your fashion is a bit basic when compared to other cosplayers this round, but I think the added levitation helps make up for that. It gives us something interesting about the shot since it would've been a bit boring, otherwise. Still, it looks true to character to me, so an overall good shot.
