Portfolio Comparison and Marking Rubric

[Janice Dickinson]

At the Top/left : Ebony Souls
At the bottom/right : Some Nondescript Japanese Chick Slayers

Photoshoot 1 - Triple Trouble

Model Potential:



Celebrity Smile:


Fictional Basic Beauty:



Photoshoot 2 - Sex Sells (Coat and Shoes vs MMO Video Game)




Photoshoot 3 - It's A Party! (Introvert at Party vs Elegant Spy Soirée)





Photoshoot #4 - Major Arcana (The Hermit vs The High Priestess)



Photoshoot #5 - Natural Elements (Water Battle)



Photoshoot #6 - Seven Lucky Gods (Daikoku: God of Agriculture vs Benzaiten: Goddess of Music) 



Photoshoot #7 - Random Acts of Modelling



Photoshoot #8 - Ultima Cosmetics

Model:



Celebrity:



Fictional Character:




Photoshoot 9 - Live Action:

Model:



Celebrity:



Fictional Character:





Photoshoot #10 - Best of the Best


Model:




Celebrity:





Fictional Character:

[Janice Dickinson]

Theme Connection: How well does it fits the theme?
Modelling Content: How well the model is selling their clothes, or other features we look for in modelling, such as elongated neck, long legs, body position, etc.
Fashion Content: How much fashion is being displayed? - Whether its commercial or high fashion, how much does it appeal to your aesthetics.
Execution: How well do all the elements come together in the end? Including quality and sizing.
Potential: Your first impression on how well the model, celebrity or fictional character could progress, keep wowing us or improve.
Sex Appeal: How sexy the picture is or how much it arouses you, etc?
Advertisement Effectiveness: How well do you think the advertisement would work on the general public?
Product Visibility: How visible is the product in question?
Presence: How present is the model or celebrity is on the runway or red carpet? How much do they stand out and how memorable are they? Imagine you were at a fashion show or on the red carpet, who would you remember?
Accuracy to Character Appearance: How physically accurate is the cosplay to the fictional character? Including Skin colour, size of model, clothing choice (Even alternate outfits). I encourage cosplaying outside of your skin colour, gender and body size, but not in this competition. If you find one that you think is stunning, please share it though, just not for your final submission...
Accuracy to Character Personality: From what you know of the fictional character's personality, how well does this image portray the non-physical qualities this character is known for?
Team Progress: From start to finish, how much has the team improved, or maintained a level of awesomeness?
Wow Factor: How much are you taken aback from the picture?
Fashion Appeal: Different to Fashion Content: This is more to how it appeals to the world of fashion. It gives leeway for artistic nudity in the best of the best photoshoot

Photoshoot #1:

Ebony Souls:
Jourdan:
Theme Connection: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Potential: /5

Alicia:
Theme Connection: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Potential: /5

Kida:
Theme Connection: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Potential: /5

JFK Slayers:
Bingbing:
Theme Connection: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Potential: /5

Rose:
Theme Connection: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Potential: /5

Lara:
Theme Connection: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Potential: /5

Photoshoot #2:

Ebony Souls:

Advertisement Effectiveness: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Sex Appeal: /5

WTF Players:

Advertisement Effectiveness: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Sex Appeal: /5

Photoshoot #3:

Ebony Souls:

Theme Connection: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Fashion Content: /5

FOX Watchers:

Theme Connection: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Fashion Content: /5

Photoshoot #4:

Ebony Souls:

Theme Connection: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Fashion Content: /5

WIFI Slayers:

Theme Connection: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Fashion Content: /5

Photoshoot #5:

Ebony Souls:

Theme Connection: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Fashion Content: /5

NBN Layers:

Theme Connection: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Fashion Content: /5

Photoshoot #6:

Ebony Souls:

Theme Connection: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Fashion Content: /5

BRB Okayers:

Theme Connection: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Fashion Content: /5

Photoshoot #7:

Ebony Souls:

Theme Connection: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Fashion Content: /5

G2G L8RZ:

Theme Connection: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Fashion Content: /5

Photoshoot #8:

Ebony Souls:
Jourdan:
Advertisement Effectiveness: /5
Product Visibility: /5
Execution: /5
Modelling Content: /5

Alicia:
Advertisement Effectiveness: /5
Product Visibility: /5
Execution: /5
Modelling Content: /5

Kida:
Advertisement Effectiveness: /5
Product Visibility: /5
Execution: /5
Modelling Content: /5

Not Juicy Taters:
Bingbing:
Advertisement Effectiveness: /5
Product Visibility: /5
Execution: /5
Modelling Content: /5

Rose:
Advertisement Effectiveness: /5
Product Visibility: /5
Execution: /5
Modelling Content: /5

Lara:
Advertisement Effectiveness: /5
Product Visibility: /5
Execution: /5
Modelling Content: /5

Photoshoot #9:

Ebony Souls:
Jourdan:
Presence: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Fashion Appeal: /5

Alicia:
Presence: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Fashion Appeal: /5

Kida:
Accuracy to Character Appearance: /5
Accuracy to Character Personality: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5

LMAO Okay:
Bingbing:
Presence: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Fashion Appeal: /5

Rose:
Presence: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Fashion Appeal: /5

Lara:
Accuracy to Character Appearance: /5
Accuracy to Character Personality: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5

Photoshoot #10

Ebony Souls:

Team Progress /10

Jourdan:
Wow Factor: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Fashion Appeal: /5

Alicia:
Wow Factor: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Fashion Appeal: /5

Kida:
Wow Factor: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Fashion Appeal: /5

NJC Slayers:

Team Progress /10

Bingbing:
Wow Factor: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Fashion Appeal: /5

Rose:
Wow Factor: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Fashion Appeal: /5

Lara:
Wow Factor: /5
Modelling Content: /5
Execution: /5
Fashion Appeal: /5

[Tier 1]

Do we put our scores in here?

[Emma Frost]

Mar 27, 2016 20:19:28 GMT -5 Tier 1 said:

Do we put our scores in here?

Either in your portfolio or pm to Janice

[Janice Dickinson]

Or here, just somewhere where the other two teams cannot see.

[Janice Dickinson]

Frostbite, Team Marvellous, Tier 1

Ready when you are.

[Tier 1]

Ok! Sorry. Will do these ASAP.

[Frostbite]

Have you ever considered posting your scoring rubric when you post photo shoots?  This game is fun but frustrating when you're not clear on what you're looking for. Had I known that my cosplay model having tattoos would have gotten me eliminated from the game, I would have found some more basic bitch picture...

[Janice Dickinson]

They're usually the same unless I say otherwise, and the jury and judging rooms from previous cycles are open to anyone to read, I'll try my best.

Sometimes photoshoots are posted in a hurry before I leave to work.

[Team Marvellous]

Ebony Souls:
Jourdan:
Theme Connection: 4/5
Modelling Content: 5/5
Execution: 5/5
Potential: 5/5

Alicia:
Theme Connection: 5/5
Modelling Content: 4/5
Execution: 3/5
Potential: 4/5

Kida:
Theme Connection: 5/5
Modelling Content: 3/5
Execution: 3/5
Potential: 4/5

JFK Slayers:
Bingbing:
Theme Connection: 5/5
Modelling Content: 4/5
Execution: 4/5
Potential: 5/5

Rose:
Theme Connection: 5/5
Modelling Content: 2/5
Execution: 2/5
Potential: 3/5

Lara:
Theme Connection: 5/5
Modelling Content: 4/5
Execution: 4/5
Potential: 4/5

Photoshoot #2:

Ebony Souls:

Advertisement Effectiveness: 5/5
Modelling Content: 5/5
Execution: 5/5
Sex Appeal: 5/5

WTF Players:

Advertisement Effectiveness: 3/5
Modelling Content: 4/5
Execution: 3/5
Sex Appeal:2/5

Photoshoot #3:

Ebony Souls:

Theme Connection: 5/5
Modelling Content: 5/5
Execution:5 /5
Fashion Content: 5/5

FOX Watchers:

Theme Connection: 2/5
Modelling Content: 2/5
Execution:2 /5
Fashion Content: 2/5

Photoshoot #4:

Ebony Souls:

Theme Connection: 3/5
Modelling Content: 3/5
Execution: 3/5
Fashion Content: 2/5

WIFI Slayers:

Theme Connection: 3/5
Modelling Content:4 /5
Execution: 4/5
Fashion Content: 4/5

Photoshoot #5:

Ebony Souls:

Theme Connection: 5/5
Modelling Content: 5/5
Execution: 4/5
Fashion Content: 4/5

NBN Layers:

Theme Connection: 3/5
Modelling Content: 3/5
Execution:2 /5
Fashion Content: 2/5

Photoshoot #6:

Ebony Souls:

Theme Connection: 4/5
Modelling Content: 5/5
Execution: 4/5
Fashion Content: 4/5

BRB Okayers:

Theme Connection: 5/5
Modelling Content: 3/5
Execution: 3/5
Fashion Content: 4/5

Photoshoot #7:

Ebony Souls:

Theme Connection: 3/5
Modelling Content: 4/5
Execution: 4/5
Fashion Content: 5/5

G2G L8RZ:

Theme Connection: 5/5
Modelling Content: 4/5
Execution: 3/5
Fashion Content: 4/5

Photoshoot #8:

Ebony Souls:
Jourdan:
Advertisement Effectiveness: 3/5
Product Visibility: 5/5
Execution: 3/5
Modelling Content: 3/5

Alicia:
Advertisement Effectiveness: 5/5
Product Visibility: 5/5
Execution: 5/5
Modelling Content:5 /5

Kida:
Advertisement Effectiveness: 4/5
Product Visibility: 4/5
Execution: 3/5
Modelling Content: 3/5

Not Juicy Taters:
Bingbing:
Advertisement Effectiveness: 5/5
Product Visibility: 5/5
Execution: 5/5
Modelling Content: 5/5

Rose:
Advertisement Effectiveness: 5/5
Product Visibility: 5/5
Execution: 4/5
Modelling Content: 3/5

Lara:
Advertisement Effectiveness: 3/5
Product Visibility: 5/5
Execution: 3/5
Modelling Content: 3/5

Photoshoot #9:

Ebony Souls:
Jourdan:
Presence: 5/5
Modelling Content: 4/5
Execution: 3/5
Fashion Appeal: 4/5

Alicia:
Presence: 4/5
Modelling Content: 3/5
Execution: 3/5
Fashion Appeal: 4/5

Kida:
Accuracy to Character Appearance: 5/5
Accuracy to Character Personality: 5/5
Modelling Content: 5/5
Execution: 5/5

LMAO Okay:
Bingbing:
Presence: 5/5
Modelling Content: 5/5
Execution: 4/5
Fashion Appeal:5 /5

Rose:
Presence: 3/5
Modelling Content: 3/5
Execution: 4/5
Fashion Appeal:5 /5

Lara:
Accuracy to Character Appearance: 5/5
Accuracy to Character Personality: 3/5
Modelling Content: 3/5
Execution: 2/5

Photoshoot #10

Ebony Souls:

Team Progress 8/10

Jourdan:
Wow Factor: 4/5
Modelling Content: 5/5
Execution: 4/5
Fashion Appeal: 5/5

Alicia:
Wow Factor: 5/5
Modelling Content: 4/5
Execution: 4/5
Fashion Appeal: /5

Kida:
Wow Factor: 4/5
Modelling Content: 3/5
Execution: 4/5
Fashion Appeal: 3/5

NJC Slayers:

Team Progress 7/10

Bingbing:
Wow Factor: 5/5
Modelling Content: 4/5
Execution: 4/5
Fashion Appeal: 5/5

Rose:
Wow Factor: 4/5
Modelling Content: 3/5
Execution: 3/5
Fashion Appeal: 3/5

Lara:
Wow Factor: 5/5
Modelling Content: 3/5
Execution: 3/5
Fashion Appeal: 3/5